Following a disappointing general election outcome, Kate Forbes, the deputy first minister, has expressed her confidence in John Swinney’s ability to restore the Scottish National Party’s (SNP) reputation for effectiveness and integrity.
Her public endorsement comes after Alex Neil, a former cabinet member, suggested that Swinney should step aside and allow either Forbes or Stephen Flynn, the SNP’s Westminster leader, to take the reins.
Neil argued that a new leader unassociated with the party’s recent struggles under Swinney and his predecessor, Nicola Sturgeon, would be beneficial. The SNP suffered a significant setback in the election, returning only nine MPs compared to 48 in 2019, as Labour secured a decisive victory on both sides of the border.
In a recent interview on BBC Radio 4’s Today program, Kate Forbes acknowledged the Scottish National Party’s (SNP) challenging election outcome, cautioning against introspection and emphasizing the need to heed the electorate’s call for change.
She stressed that the party must prioritize transparency and openness in its governance, which she believes John Swinney, the first minister, is committed to upholding.
Forbes supported Swinney’s leadership, highlighting his focus on competence and integrity throughout the election cycle. She emphasized that these principles must guide the party’s actions, and she is confident that Swinney is the leader who will achieve this vision. By planting the flags of transparency and openness, the SNP can move forward and rebuild trust with the electorate.
Alex Neil, a former cabinet colleague of John Swinney’s, has urged the party to replace its leader, suggesting that the time has come for a new generation to take the reins. In an interview with the Herald newspaper, Neil singled out Kate Forbes and Stephen Flynn as potential successors, emphasizing the need for fresh leadership.
His sentiments echo former SNP MPs Joanna Cherry and Angus MacNeil, who have also criticized the party’s leadership under Nicola Sturgeon’s tenure. Meanwhile, Stephen Flynn, who narrowly retained his Aberdeen South seat, has called for the party to confront the election results with “brutal honesty,” while expressing support for Swinney’s continued leadership.
In a candid op-ed published somewhere, Stephen Flynn, MP for Aberdeen South, emphasized the need for the Scottish National Party to embrace honesty and humility to regain the trust of voters who either supported other parties or abstained from the election.
Flynn acknowledged that the party’s internal struggles in recent years had served as a diversion, creating a perception that the SNP was out of touch with the everyday concerns and experiences of the people it serves. By acknowledging and learning from these mistakes, the party can rebuild connections with those who feel disconnected.
Toni Guigliano, the SNP’s unsuccessful candidate in Falkirk, attributed the party’s loss of its previously safest seat to Labour as a voter rebuke, saying the electorate wanted to send a message that the SNP needed to “get its house in order.”
However, Guigliano absolved John Swinney of blame, instead citing a scandal involving local MSP Michael Matheson, the former health secretary, as a significant factor in his campaign.
Matheson’s alleged misuse of public funds, resulting in an £11,000 bill on his parliamentary device, was a daily topic of concern for voters on the doorstep, Guigliano told BBC Radio Scotland’s Drivetime, emphasizing the need for the SNP to prioritize trust and transparency moving forward.
“Extremely challenging situation”
According to Toni Guigliano, the Scottish National Party (SNP) has lost touch with the public’s sentiment on independence, with the party essentially engaging in an internal monologue rather than actively engaging with voters.
He cautioned that the SNP’s insular approach to strategy over the past year has only exacerbated this disconnect. Furthermore, Guigliano highlighted the ongoing police investigation into the party’s financial dealings as a significant concern, noting that the party’s lack of transparency and accountability has left many questions unanswered.
This dearth of answers has created a challenging situation for the SNP in a democratic system that values openness and accountability.
As investigations into the alleged embezzlement of SNP funds continue, Peter Murrell, the party’s former chief executive and husband of Nicola Sturgeon, has been charged. Despite this, Ian Blackford, the former SNP Westminster leader, believes that John Swinney should be allowed to lead the party and government, stating that a leadership change is unnecessary.
In an interview with BBC Radio’s Good Morning Scotland, Blackford acknowledged that voters in the recent election were primarily concerned with the cost of living and public services. Looking ahead to the 2026 Holyrood election, he emphasized the need for the SNP to construct a compelling narrative highlighting the importance of independence in addressing Scotland’s challenges.
Jonathan is an avid automobile enthusiast who is passionate about all things on wheels. From the latest car models to classic vintage rides, I love exploring the automotive world’s intricate details and engineering marvels. With years of experience in test-driving, reviewing, and analyzing cars, I provide readers with comprehensive insights and honest opinions.